🔗 Share this article

According to newly revealed information from Embark Studios, Arc Raiders appears to make use of AI tools for generating select spoken content. This revelation strongly echoes the situation that arose with the studio's earlier release, The Finals.

Title Introduction

Debuted on October 30th for Sony's console, Windows PC, and Microsoft's console, Arc Raiders is described as a more accessible entry point to the competitive survival genre. Compared to complex games like Escape from Tarkov, it aims to offer a more approachable adventure. The title has largely been favorable reviews, presently achieving a excellent score on Steam based on over 8,000 player reviews.

Development Approach

Via the game's official platform description, a notice regarding artificially created material raises similarities: Throughout creation, we might apply automated and generative tools to assist with asset production. Regardless of method, the resulting game showcases the artistic expression of our creative personnel."

Previous Controversy

The Finals, a popular competitive FPS known for its smooth gunplay and destructive environments, faced criticism for its implementation of artificial intelligence prior to its official launch. Throughout its October 2023 open beta, the project's audio lead mentioned in a online discussion that the development team had used generative technology for developing voice content. This announcement generated instant negative reaction from industry talent and creative personnel, who claimed that AI-generated voices were of reduced caliber compared to human performances and that such practices could displace acting roles.

Company Position

Reacting to feedback, Embark Studios explained that they had employed skilled performers to create initial dialogue for The Finals, but enhanced these with TTS technology to create extra lines based on those original recordings. The studio's rationale centered on the development speed achieved through this approach.

Present Circumstances

Regarding Arc Raiders, the game's design director recently stated that the game does not employ AI generation in any form," though he declined to elaborate on the specific interpretation of the store notice. He did admit, however, that the identical voice system implemented in The Finals was also applied in Arc Raiders.

Our approach involves blend of recorded voice audio and audio generated via synthetic voice systems in our titles, based on the context," commented a development team member. "Sometimes, filming actual interactions where actors get together — enabling performance dynamics and tension to shape the outcome — is something that provides substance to our digital universes that technology can't emulate. In other instances, particularly if it concerns real-time combat communications, synthetic voice permits us to have tailored VO where we could not for example due to production timelines."

Community Response

Initial response to the incorporation of automated systems in Arc Raiders has been relatively mixed, particularly in the initial period. Certain gamers have shown clear disapproval.

• Synthetic speech represents a blemish on an mostly outstanding experience," wrote one gamer in a online discussion.
• I oppose that they used it in The Finals and am sad to hear they employed it once more for this title," responded another.
• The result was immediately noticeable in the dialogue delivery for one protagonist," noted a different user.

Nevertheless, other players have adopted a more accepting stance.

• "Don't give a fuck, they compensated performers and used it well," wrote one online participant.
• "This is as ethical as it is possible nowadays, unfortunately," continued another.

The continuing discussion about AI implementation in game development seems likely to endure as developers weigh production speed with creative quality and responsible practices.